Thursday, May 6, 2010

How was it decided what books would make up the New Testament? (Level 2 discussion)

Before reading below, I recommend you read my earlier post - Is the Bible the inspired word of God?
The New Testament canon is the set of 27 Biblical books from the first century that is considered to be the “inspired word of God.” What were the criteria for deciding what books should be canonized? To begin, it should be immediately noted that the church did not “determine” the canon of Scripture. This incorrect notion has been popularized in modern times by provocative movies and best-selling books. A more accurate understanding would be that the church recognized what books carried the qualities of inspiration and authority. New Testament scholar F.F. Bruce has stated, “The New Testament canon was not demarcated by the arbitrary decree of any Church Council. When at last a Church Council—the Synod of Hippo in A.D. 393—listed the twenty-seven books of the New Testament, it did not confer upon them any authority which they did not already possess, but simply recorded their previously established canonicity."[1]
What qualities were necessary for a first-century book to be canonized as the inspired “word of God”? There were four major criteria for canonical selection. The first is apostolic authority. This simply means that a first-century apostle (or a close associate) must have written the book in question. For example, Matthew, John, Paul, James, and Peter were apostles and were responsible for writing what makes up most of the New Testament. In situations where the author was not an apostle (as was the case with Mark and Luke), they were known to be close associates with an apostle. The second major criterion is antiquity. This established that the writing emerged from the apostolic era/age of the eyewitnesses. There were many fanciful writings that surfaced in the second-century claiming to have been written by an apostle of Jesus, but their false testimony was well-known. Only a writing from the first-century would even be considered to be canonized. The third criterion is orthodoxy, in that, the writing must align with acceptable apostolic doctrine. Finally, the fourth criterion is catholicity, which states that the universal church had accepted the doctrine and found it edifying to their personal faith. Ultimately, there is no question that “Scripture is the Word of God because the Holy Spirit says so, not because the church says so.”[2] And the church was simply being faithful to this truth.

[1] Quoted in Kenneth Richard Samples, A World of Difference. (Grand Rapids: BakerBooks, 2007), 115.
[2] Samples, 116.

Moral relativism or objective morality? (Level 1 discussion)

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?
This is a Level 1 discussion, because the question of God's existence is closely related to the source of morality. If naturalism is true (and God does not exist), then moral relativism is true. If God does exist, then objective morality is true, because humans are then not the "inventors" or morality.
Moral relativism is the view that there are no universally valid moral truths. According to this view, morality is completely dependent on personal belief or opinion. This view is the result of various anthropological studies, which have observed various cultures practicing apparent differing ethical standards. What are we to make of the fact that some cultures more readily practice euthanasia on the sick and elderly or commit a relatively high number of abortions? In numerous western societies, many view these actions as “merciful” or a matter of “personal choice.” Likewise, in these same societies, there are those who view these acts as “murder.” Doesn’t the fact that these views are opposed to each other (and the fact that we cannot seem to find agreement) imply that more relativism is true? Furthermore, moral relativism has found even more strength in our current postmodern context. Postmodernism has completely undermined the existence of objective truth and has perpetuated the idea that there is no “meta-narrative” (or “story” that applies to everyone). Furthermore, in our postmodern context, the desire for truth is being replaced with the desire for pragmatism. People, including Christians, want to be told why living a particular way works better, not why living a particular way is right or wrong.
Objective morality, on the other hand, teaches that morality is completely independent of personal beliefs or opinions. According to this view, morality is not something that is “invented” but is something that is discovered. Examples of objective moral claims would be statements such as, “murder is wrong,” “rape is wrong,” or “torturing children for fun is wrong.” These are thought to be “objective” and “universal” moral claims, because it does not matter what people believe regarding these assertions. These assertions are thought to be just as true as “2 + 2 = 4.” In fact, even if a meteor destroyed the planet and no humans survived, these moral claims would still be true.
Now that I have explained both views fully, I will now refute moral relativism and argue in favor of objective morality. First, moral relativism cannot be justified simply by the fact that there are various ethical standards within cultures or even between cultures. Logically, it is a non-sequitur (does not follow). The fact that Culture A and Culture B disagree about the truthfulness of X does not necessitate that Culture A and Culture B must both be correct about the truthfulness of X! In fact, the Law of Non-Contradiction prevents both from being correct (assuming they logically contradict one another), although it is possible for both cultures to be incorrect. Furthermore, we might be thinking too “shallow” if we conclude that a culture that disagrees about the morality of abortion is actually differing on a moral principle. Although the issue of abortion has enormous moral implications, the fact is the argument is over the facts – not the morality! Pro-Choice proponents tend to be just as opposed to “murder” as Pro-Life proponents. The disagreement is about whether abortion is, in fact, “murder.” This extends to the actual metaphysical argument of personhood. As a Pro-Life proponent myself, I can assure you there is no “middle ground” on this issue. Obviously, if a Pro-Life proponent literally believes an unborn child is a “person,” and that terminating the pregnancy would be murder, it would be highly immoral for the Pro-Life proponent to compromise.
Not only does moral relativism fail, but also “objective morality” is intuitively known and proven to be correct. This is clear from the moral claims I stated above. I propose that cognizant, sane people immediately know that murder is wrong and that committing such an act is inherently shameful. It is not merely “wrong” because of the time-period and/or culture one is found. If this is not true, then (presumably) Hitler was not morally wrong, because in his time and context, he personally believed he was doing something good by committing genocide. Such a view is repulsive to our basic intuition.

Is the Bible the inspired word of God? (Level 2 discussion)

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?

To begin, there are six good reasons to believe that the Bible is God’s actual revelation to mankind:[1]
1. The Bible is a religious book connected to history; therefore, it is open to verification via historical investigation.
2. The claims of many Scriptural accounts have been verified through extra-biblical and archaeological evidence.
3. The abundance and integrity of thousands of manuscripts of the Biblical text far surpasses all other ancient literary works, whether secular or religious.
4. The Bible presents a view of the beginning of the universe – that there was a singular beginning to space, matter, energy, and time – which matches well with the most prevalent views of modern science.
5. The Bible appeals to specific miracles and prophecies, which can be evaluated in terms of their historical accuracy and explanatory power.
6. The Bible presents a realistic view of the human condition (their nature and predicament) and offers a rational, viable, and existentially fulfilling resolution for humanity.
Those reasons listed above are good external factors that give validity to the inspiration of Scripture. There are a number of internal factors, found in both the Old and New Testaments, which give further credibility to the claim that the Holy Bible is the inspired word of God. In the Old Testament, God spoke words to Moses who then proclaimed them to Israel. This occurs numerous times in the Torah, with the clearest example found in the giving of the Ten Commandments. Furthermore, the New Testament treats the Old Testament as inspired. In fact, many passages in the Old Testament are attributed to God by the authors of the New Testament writings. 2 Timothy 3:16 states, “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness” (NIV, italics mine). Furthermore, the apostles regarded their preaching and teaching as God’s word. Acts 8:14 states, “Now when the apostles in Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received the word of God…” (NASB, italics mine). Paul also states in Galatians 1:11-12, “For I would have you know, brethren, that the gospel which was preached by me is not according to man. For I neither received it from man, nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Jesus Christ” (NASB). Finally, in Peter’s own letter (dated to the early 60’s), he actually refers to Paul’s writings as “Scripture.” Peter mentions that Paul’s letters have some things that are hard to understand, “which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures…” (2 Peter 3:16 NASB, italics mine). Therefore, there are external factors and internal evidence that both the Old and New Testaments of the Bible are inspired words of God.

[1] Summarized from quote in Kenneth Richard Samples, A World of Difference. (Grand Rapids: BakerBooks, 2007), 111.

How has God revealed Himself?

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?

How has the Creator God revealed Himself to His creation? There are two broad terms that are used to characterize God’s revelation. They are “general revelation” and “special revelation.” General revelation is the way in which God has generally revealed himself to all of His creation. “God’s existence, power, wisdom, majesty, and glory are made known in a general way to all people at all times in all places through the created order. That includes nature (Ps. 19:1-4; Rom. 1:18-21), history (Dan. 2:21; Acts 17:26), and the inner human conscience (Gen. 1:26-27; Rom. 2:11-16).”[1] The most important and often quoted Biblical support for this truth is found in Romans 1:20: “For since the creation of the world His invisible qualities, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse” (NASB). Because Paul is speaking about general revelation, it should be noted that this verse is not true only because it is found in inerrant Scripture. Rather, it is the case that this verse is simply stating a fact about reality. So even if this verse (or any other similar verse) were not in the Bible, general revelation could still be taught.
When studying the created order, one can conclude many things about the One who put it there. First, the Creator must be enormously powerful. For who, but a very powerful Being, could create all things out of nothing? Second, the Creator must be supremely intelligent. There is a clear sign of intelligence evident in creation. For example, imagine showing a bird to someone who had never seen or heard of such a thing. What if you told that person that this “bird” was an early twenty-first century invention by some of our brightest scientists? Upon studying this “invention,” the person you have fibbed to would be mesmerized and enormously impressed by the scientists who were able to create such a design. When discovering that this bird was actually a natural creature like all other animals, it would be foolish for the duped person to become any less impressed with the design and intricacies of this bird creature. When understanding it this way, one can see how intelligent design and enormous power were both necessary in establishing the created order. We should not ignore these conclusions any more than we would ignore the deduction that human intelligence is always behind a completed Scrabble board. Furthermore, there are other aspects of God’s general revelation found in creation (the moral law is an additional example).
General revelation will only reveal that God exists and that He has certain attributes. Special revelation is the way in which God has revealed Himself in a more specific and personal way. “First, God manifested himself through his covenant people such as the Hebrew patriarchs, prophets, and kings (as recorded and interpreted by the prophets in the Old Testament). Second, God’s revelation culminated decisively in the Incarnation of Jesus Christ—the God-man whose life, death, and resurrection were recorded and interpreted by the apostles in the New Testament.”[2] Miraculous acts and visions/dreams from God are additional examples of God’s special revelation. Protestant theologians often refer to this dual view of revelation as the “two-books theory.” God is both the author of the figurative book of nature (general revelation) and the literal book of Scripture (special revelation). Both the world and His written word reveal that God exists and desires a relationship with His creation.
In the context of the Faith Pyramid, general revelation is used to "conquer" Level 1, and special revelation is used to conquer Levels 2 & up.

[1] Kenneth Richard Samples, A World of Difference. (Grand Rapids: BakerBooks, 2007), 109.
[2] Samples, 110.

Sunday, March 21, 2010

Our Privileged Planet (Level 1 Discussion)

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?

Earth is a "privileged" planet. If the attributes of our planet were any different, there could be no complex life on Earth. What should we conclude from the evidence? That we are the product of an intelligent and purposeful Designer.

  • Large Moon - For a world the size of the Earth, our moon is unusually large. But if our moon didn't exist, neither would we! The gravitational pull of the moon stabilizes the Earth's axis. This insures temperate seasonal changes and the only climate in the solar system mild enough to allow for complex life.
  • Jupiter - If a planet the size of the Jupiter did not exist, the Earth would be bombarded with space material. Jupiter's gravitational field attracts asteroids and comets that might otherwise strike Earth. The planet has been called the "Cosmic Vacuum Cleaner" of the solar system.
  • Water - Several factors about water are required for life to exist. Liquid water is a must for life to exist on a planet, and the chemical properties of water are perfectly suited for carbon-based life forms. And water absorbs heat from the sun, which is critical to regulate the surface temperature of a planet.
  • Earth's Distance from the Sun - If the Earth were very much closer to the sun, all water would evaporate from the surface. If the Earth were much farther from the sun, all water would freeze.
  • Earth's Crust - On Earth, the terrestrial crust is "paper-thin." The crust of the planet is perfect to regulate the planet's temperature and fulfills a number of other important factors for life to exist.
  • Magnetic Field - The magnetic field protects our planet from the solar winds of the sun. If our planet was smaller, or the magnetic field weaker, these winds would strip away our atmosphere altogether.
  • Oxygen/Nitrogen Atmosphere - Our atmosphere is yet another important factor to sustain life. Complex life requires an oxygen/nitrogen atmosphere.
  • Oxygen Level - Oxygen comprises 21% of the Earth's atmosphere. If it were 25%, fires would erupt and if it were 15%, humans would suffocate.
  • Water Vapor - If water vapor levels in the atmosphere were greater than they are now, a greenhouse effect would cause temperatures to rise too high for human life; if they were less, the Earth would get too cold to support life.
  • Earth's Rotation - If the rotation of the Earth took longer than 24 hours, temperature differences would be too great between night and day. If the rotation period were shorter, wind velocities would be too great.
  • Earth's Tilt - The 23-degree axial tilt of the Earth is just right. If the tilt were altered slightly, surface temperatures would be too extreme on Earth.
  • Earth's Orbit - Earth's orbit is nearly circular. If Earth's orbit were very elliptical, life would be destroyed due to temperature changes, because we would get too close and too far from the sun every year.
  • Jupiter's Orbit - Jupiter has a nearly circular orbit (similar to Earth's). If Jupiter's orbit were very elliptical, its gravity would cause Earth's orbit to become irregular, which would prevent life on our planet from surviving the temperature changes.

I have only provided a dozen or so examples of our planet's "privileged" status as a life-supporting home for complex life in the universe. There are countless other examples which also serve as evidence that we are not the result of a great cosmic "accident" but rather an intentional and powerful Creator God.

[NOTE: All of the examples above were taken from "I Don't Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist" by Norman Geisler & Frank Turek, "The Creator and the Cosmos" by Hugh Ross, and "The Privileged Planet" by Guillermo Gonzalez & Jay Richards.]

Friday, March 12, 2010

The difference between Creationism and Intelligent Design theory (Level 1 discussion)

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?

Predictably, many Darwinists and far too many media pundits have painted Intelligent Design theory (ID) as "Creationism in disguise," but this is terribly misleading and is the direct result of either unfortunate ignorance or willful disingenuousness. Where the train derails is when Intelligent Design theory is thought to presuppose the existence of God. This is when it is often mischaracterized as simply being "creationism in disguise." In fact, a quick Google search of "intelligent design theory creationism is disguise" will achieve over 54,000 hits! The reason this is a misunderstanding of ID is because it is actually "creationism" that has theism as its presupposition - not Intelligent Design theory. This is where they differ. In essence, "I believe in God; therefore, I'm a creationist" is the logical flow of the argument. This is not a scientific argument - In fairness, creationism is not trying to be a scientific argument. It is simply a statement of belief. Of course, "creationism" is no more guilty than naturalism/materialism of adopting a particular religious belief. Truthfully, "materialism" (the philosophy that everything that exists is matter) is atheistic by definition. In fact, it could be argued that ID is the least religious view of the three, because (with ID) the existence of God is very much a logical implication of the theory; however, it is not a presupposition of the theory. Propositionally, it could be understood the following way:
  1. Atheism (religious belief) --> Materialism or Naturalism (philosophy) --> Darwinism (view of origin)
  2. Theism (religious belief) --> Creationism (view of origin) --> "Supernatural-ism" (philosophy)
  3. Intelligent Design (view of origin) --> Theism (religious belief) --> "Supernatural-ism" (philosophy)
Notice that materialism has atheism as its foundation (or precursor) - truly, they are synonymous. This logically leads to Darwinism, or the view that mankind has descended from a common ancestor, via natural selection and genetic mutation. With #2, the religious belief of theism necessitates creationism as the view of origin. This, in turn, leads to the belief or "philosophy" that God supernaturally works in the world. With Intelligent Design theory (#3), notice how it is one's view and study of mankind's origin that implies or leads to a belief in God. And, as with #2, "supernatural-ism" logically follows from there. This is truly a scientific argument, because it is the study of the data that has created the conclusion. There is no religious belief or philosophy (or metaphysical presumption) that is necessitating a certain view of the origin of mankind.

Check back for further posts on Intelligent Design theory and how beneficial it can be for "Level 1" discussion - for the purpose of converting someone to theism.

Friday, March 5, 2010

The Depth Chart

Before reading below, I recommend you read my post - What is the Faith Pyramid?

When it comes to being able to proclaim a truth (or even an opinion), I believe there are varying stages of "understanding" as illustrated below. (Note: The "stages" are
superior as they descend, because this chart is meant to connote "depth" of understanding). 

1. BELIEF [or assertion]
("I believe that Jesus rose from the dead.")

2. REASONS for belief
("I believe that Jesus rose from the dead, because of A, B, & C")

3. EXPLANATION of reasons
("I can explain A, B, & C")

4. DEFENSE of reasons
("I can defend A, B, & C")

For the sake of an evangelistic/apologetics encounter, it's important for a Christian to achieve the deepest stage of understanding and, therefore, a sound proclamation of truth. There are far too many Christians who possess only a first or second stage of understanding in many of their beliefs. A true Christian worldview is developed only at the bottom half of the chart. How deep are you?